Have a question and don't know who to ask? The Guru can give you in-depth answers to all kinds of questions. The process for university admission can be a long and detailed one - wondering how to get started? Ask away. Or, check out the long list of topics already covered by the Guru to see if anyone else is wondering the same thing.
The Guru on MyCollegeGuide.org is a unique college resource that speaks directly to your questions and concerns - no form letter replies and no generalizations. If you have a question or problem concerning college admissions, the Guru can help!
Special Questions
I just received my AP exam scores in the mail. I got a 3 in U.S. History but only a 1 in chemistry and physics. I realize that colleges are going to look at all of my scores, but if I did well in the actual class (high A's to mid B's), will the scores be a deciding factor for admission? Would I have been better to have just not taken those two exams, or are colleges going to appreciate the risk, even if the outcome was bad? Also, one specific college I am looking at for early decision only accepts 4's and 5's. Next year, should I only take the exams that I feel confident I can receive those scores in? I don't want to take the exam for every AP class I take if it's actually going to hurt me in the long run!
Colleges will give greater weight to your actual grades in the classes than to your AP scores, at least for admissions purposes. (Course placement is another matter; most colleges won’t give credit for anything below a 3.) Having said that, I would recommend taking only those AP exams you feel confident about in the future. It looks much better to have fewer, higher AP scores than a bunch of lower scores. In a nutshell; Don’t worry about the scores you’ve already received, but take only the exams you feel confident about this coming year.
top
If I am looking towards a career as an attorney and eventually moving into politics, should I take a double major in college? Some of the schools I am looking at don't offer a pre-law program. What majors do future law students usually take as an undergraduate? Thank you for your help!
I don’t think a double major is necessary. The problem with double majors is that they don’t leave you much room to take other classes that interest you; you’re so busy fulfilling your major requirements that there’s no space left in your schedule. I also wouldn’t worry about applying to colleges that don’t have pre-law programs. There really aren't any required undergraduate courses for law school, so the implication that a "pre-law" programs involves certain required courses isn't correct. Common majors for law school applicants include political science, history, and English. However, you can have a completely different major. I encourage you to pick a major that excites you, although you don't have to worry about this right away. The important thing is to do well in your undergraduate courses whatever major you choose.
top
I have a question about what the difference is between attending college in the Fall or in the Spring, with regards to classes, housing, graduation, and freshman orientation. Thank you.
I would refer you to individual colleges with this question. It may be harder at some schools to get the housing and classes you want if you start college in the spring. Then again, it might not be a problem. The one clear advantage to starting school in the fall is social: It’s much easier to meet people and make friends when everyone is new and in the same boat. Assuming you take the required course loads each semester, starting in the fall also means you’ll graduate with your classmates (which wouldn’t happen if you started in the spring, unless you took extra courses in future semesters).
top
I am currently a junior in high school, but I am also going to college full time and getting high school and college credits. I didn't do so well in the college classes my first semester except for one class, but my high school grades were all A's. I really want to go to a liberal arts school. My first choices are New York University and Berkley, but I don't know what to do! Can you help me?
If you're getting all A's in high school then you'll have a shot at going to NYU or Berkley. The colleges shouldn't hold against you the grades you get in college courses. However, I would advise that you check with the colleges you're interested in to make sure they will give you credit for the courses you've taken. Also, I would make getting good high school grades a priority, and, therefore, would suggest you not overburden your time commitment to the college courses.
top
Our 8th grade public school daughter has been doing EPGY math for a couple of years in lieu of our school curriculum. She likes it and the rigor of the course seems more suited to her math ability. Any info from colleges if she stays with EPGY through high school level courses (hence no math grade included in transcripts)? As she plans for hs classes, is a 4.0 in standard hs fare better than a high 3+ average in higher level classes?
EPGY isn't going to be as well-known to some colleges as, say, AP math level classes, and although I'm not sure about this, I don't think EPGY courses will be accepted for college credit. Obviously EPGY has a great reputation, though. Typically, a high 3+ in more challenging classes would fare better. If you get a 4.0/4.0, who's to say what you were really capable of?
top
Thanks for offering such a candid guide for students and parents. My question concerns admission rates for out-of-state and out-of-country applicants. I've heard that Virginia universities, specifically UVA and William and Mary, have quotas for out-of-state applicants. The rumor is that they can only have 10% of the student body be non-residents. Is this true? Also, my daughter is very interested in McGill University in Montreal. We visited, and she plans to apply, but I can't find information on her likelihood of admission (beyond the minimum grade and score requirements). I know McGill has become hot for Americans, partially due to the exchange rate, but how many Americans do they accept there each year? Is there a quota?
Public state schools such as UVA and William and Mary very definitely have quotas on in and out-of-state students, which are typically set by the state legislature. I really think this is fair. Residents of the state pay taxes to support these schools, and they should be the primary beneficiary of these efforts. I'm sorry I can't be of help about McGill. My best advice is to call or email them; I'm sure they would give you the straight scoop.
top
I have noticed that some colleges report the percentage of first year students that do not return for their second year at that school. What is a normal percentage to expect? What does it mean to me when it is abnormally high or low?
Freshman retention and graduation rates are numbers that all colleges would have access to. In fact, colleges must report graduation rates as part of their requirements for federal financial assistance. Colleges like to see freshman retention in the 90% plus range. If a college reports a lower freshman retention, you should ask why, but don’t assume that a lower number is be a bad thing. Many colleges thrive on preparing students for transfer to other schools. These schools accept that as an important function, and they often do their jobs well. Larger, more prestigious schools have also come to accept the value of a transfer student, and over the years, have done much to ease the burden for students of transitions. Still, a highly selective college which can’t boast a graduation rate of 75% or more should be looked at carefully. And any college where you plan to stay until graduation that has a graduation rate under 50% should definitely generate more questions from you as to why.
top
I want to apply to Rutgers University in New Jersey. My mother lives in New Jersey, but I live in NY with friends so that I could finish my senior year. My mother will be paying for my college tuition. On my application, should I declare my mom's address in NJ? Will I get the NJ in-state tuition cost?
If your mother is your legal guardian, and you are under 18, your permanent address is her home in New Jersey, and you would be considered a legal resident of New Jersey. For example, if I attended prep school in another state and then returned to my home state for college, I would not be considered a resident of my prep school state. It’s basically the same thing. I can’t imagine there being a disagreement over this, but to be sure, you should call the Rutgers admissions office and ask for a copy of their residency requirements. Every school has them.
top
I work at an alternative school engaged in the debate over having National Honor Society. To what degree would being in National Honor Society benefit students admission into the best colleges?
The National Honor Society is perhaps the most recognizable academic achievement award available to high school students. I believe that in our society today, student achievements need to be recognized in a positive way. Look at the attention we give our high school basketball stars compared to how we honor our academic achievers. Student participation in the National Honor Society is also a growth experience which helps the student develop a variety of skills including leadership and presence. Highly selective colleges look for these attributes. Thus, I can think of nothing but positive benefits to your school and its students for making such a program available.
top
Will participating in conservative Republican political causes hurt my chances of getting into a liberal Ivy League college?
OK, these are opinions, here, from the editors of FishNet since no admissions person is going to admit to this kind of discrimination. Frankly, colleges do look for “fit” and some activities (not just political ones) may not play well on an application. I think you have to think carefully about how you present such activities, if you present them all. For example, most political groups advocate some kind of restraint on government spending, but there are wide differences on how to get the job done. Still, you could play up your involvement in “controlling government spending” without saying you want to cut welfare to the bone. Hey, politicians do it all the time. You don’t want to distort your application, but think carefully about how the information about you will be construed. By the way, what makes you think Ivy League schools are liberal? You might be surprised at what you find.
top
I am a parent of a child in a middle school. I am planning to relocate to Atlanta. I am considering both public and private high schools for my child. I would like to find a high school with a good track record for getting students into selective colleges. Do you have any suggestions on how to do that without calling every school individually?
I believe the College Board publishes or can provide the SAT average scores of high schools. This would be an excellent indication of the performance of those schools. On the other hand, I think choosing the right learning environment is more important for your child than basing a decision purely on test scores. I would select a short list of three to five schools based on test scores and then personally visit each school with my child.
top
What's the difference between universities and colleges?
Historically, universities offer both bachelor’s degree programs and graduate and doctoral degree programs. Colleges typically offer only bachelor’s degree programs. However, some colleges are also beginning to offer a few graduate programs.
top
I am graduating with my bachelors degree in Sociology with a concentration in Human Services and a minor in Women's Studies. I do not want to attend traditional grad school. My ideal plan would be to spend each semester in a new locale (Thailand, Mexico, Ukraine, etc.) doing service learning and taking classes to obtain a master's degree. Have you ever heard of a program similar to that? Thank you!
I sure have heard of something like that. It's called the Peace Corps! In reality that's probably going to be the closest thing to what you're speaking of, although you might not be traveling to a whole bunch of separate locations. Check out this link for information on how to
obtain a master's degree while you're doing service overseas. Otherwise you may want to just focus on obtaining an online master's degree while you're traveling around to different places. There's honestly not much out there for a "traveling master's degree" as you're speaking of, although there are a few opportunities for dual-degree, dual-host college programs.
Maybe your idea is an innovative higher education proposal for the future. Actually, for your master's thesis you could maybe even propose developing a program like that (hint, hint).
Good luck!
top
I attended a four year university and was suspended for disciplinary probation for two semesters. In the meantime, I attended the community college close by and never reapplied to the four-year, which would have lifted the suspension. I did terribly academically in both schools, but now that I've regrouped, I want to start over in another state and start again at a four year college. However, before I fill out any applications, I need to know (as though I just seemed to have taken two years off after high school) whether or not the college I apply to will find out 1) that I've attended other colleges, 2) that I was put on academic probation, and 3) that I was suspended for disciplinary probation. Couldn't I just apply with my high school transcripts and they'd never know?
No. You should always tell the truth! It will come back to you sooner or later if you try to cover up information. (Please see the previous question I answered on our website.) You say, "I've regrouped." Well, you must prove it by being honest.
Instead, you may want to ask your preferred institution about academic renewal (some schools offer programs by which you start with a "clean slate" after a certain amount of time has passed). The admissions officers and you may decide together whether that option is a path worth pursuing. You should also inquire into whether your past school and new school have any sort of academic forgiveness policy that you could apply to your situation. But again, I repeat: Do not lie on your application. That does not start you off with a good reputation, and if you are caught, any admission you gain could easily be revoked.
top
How do you apply for international colleges? Are international harder to get into?
Hi there. Thanks for your question. Luckily, the answer is pretty straightforward. If you're going to college overseas, you will be considered an "international student." Now, for each international school you are thinking of applying to, check to see if there is a specific application for international students (this is typically online, or you can contact the school for an application by mail). If there is no separate international application, then fill out a traditional application and mark it accordingly or write in that you are an international applicant. If you are accepted, a bonus could be that you might get specific kinds of financial aid or scholarships that are doled out only to international students.
Now for the second part of your question: Are international colleges harder to get into? Not necessarily...well, of course, unless you're hoping to get into Oxford or Cambridge or one of the other top-ranked-in-the-whole-world universities. Again, it just depends on the school. Some schools reserve spots specifically for international students. Others admit everyone based on their academic merit, no matter where they are from. Your best bet in every case is to check with each university specifically. Or check with your high school advisor or even the Office of International Study at a nearby college. Keep in mind that a wonderful option is to do a long-term study abroad program through a U.S. college. A lot of times it's easier than just applying straight to an international school, because the U.S. "home" college will help you get to the country, find a place to live, sometimes provide language tutoring, and provide you with various other forms of support (instead of you just trying to put all the details together on your own). Good luck as you explore your options.
top
If I apply to a new college...can that new college find out if I don't list ALL the colleges that I was at previously? I am an undergraduate transferring from a technical college to a university now. But before the technical college I attended a private university. Unfortunately, I could not afford the school, and I was booted out. Due to monetary problems, I still cannot pay them the hefty amount that I owe...but I do know I still have that bill. I assume this would be read into as leaving a college in bad standing (when it is asked on college applications)...? Do they check?
That is a good assumption to make. In college admissions, as in life, remember that telling the truth is important! If you are asked to list all the colleges you have attended previously, then by all means, list all the colleges you have attended previously! You should always assume that this new institution will be able to obtain the list of colleges you've previously attended, so you should probably just provide them that list. I also cannot suggest to you enough that you take every measure to pay off your old bill as soon as humanly possible. Get a second job; raise money; contact the finance/accounts office at your previous institution and beg for mercy as well as for help constructing a plan to pay that tuition. They will certainly want to assist you in recovering their debt. Chances are they're going to hold your transcripts until you pay up anyway, and greater chances are they're charging you interest by the month, so what are you waiting for?
top
I'm currently in the Army and I'm serving in Iraq. I've been debating on getting out, but I'm leaning more toward staying in. Even if I decide to stay in, I still want to have a plan to fall back on. You never know with today's military and the circumstances we are in. My dilemma is that with me being in the military and being only 19 years old, I have no idea as to what I would want to do outside of the military. I have no hidden talents, no work experience, and no idea as to what I'm good at. All I know is that I've been in the military going on 3 years, and I've adapted to it. Are there any suggestions as to what I should look into?
Thanks for your question! It sounds to me like you do appreciate your experience in the military and could certainly stay longer if you decide that. You can certainly succeed if you do that; there are plenty of continuing job opportunities for those who have entered and seem to be a good fit in the service for the long haul.
Now, I noticed you mentioned this: "I have no hidden talents, no work experience, and no idea as to what I'm good at." What I would like you to consider is that you probably DO have talents that you don't realize, and you do have work experience as it relates to the military. What are your main jobs on a day-to-day basis? What was your favorite part of your boot camp training?--your first months in the military? What parts did you excel at? Which came more easily to you? That might be a first step to figuring out the kinds of things you prefer to do or study.
Another thing I suggest you do is to think back to when you were a kid. What activities would you do that seemed to make time go by really fast? Did you love dinosaurs? Sports? Drawing? What subjects in school just flew by (as opposed to the classes where you stared at the clock every three minutes)? That is another key to unlocking what you enjoy and are good at. Think about projects you worked on that you were proud of, or times when you felt like you accomplished something big. All these are clues for you to think about.
I hope that gives you a start. Thank you very much for serving in the military, and I wish you all the best in your future inside or outside the service.
top